City streets are usually paved with asphalt concrete because this material gives good service and is relatively inexpensive to construct and maintain. We show that making asphalt pavements cooler, by increasing their reflection of sunlight, may lead to longer lifetime ofthe pavement, lower initial costs of the asphalt binder, and savings on street lighting and signs. Excessive glare due to the whiter surface is not likely to be a problem.
Introduction
In an earlier report (Pomerantz & Akbari 1998), the air-conditioning energy and smog reductions that might result from the use of whiter paving materials were estimated. In this paper we consider some of the collateral effects ofwhiter pavements — on their durability and on illumination they produce. Asphalt pavements are the most common street pavements in cities because they are relatively inexpensive to construct and maintain, and they give acceptable service. Such pavements are dark colored because a dark binder (asphalt) is coated onto stony aggregate in order to glue the aggregate into a rigid paving material. A newly constructed asphalt concrete’ (AC) pavement thus has the color ofthe asphalt, which is quite black. The color of the pavement has several important environmental consequences. AC contributes to sunlight’s heating of the air near the surface(Pomerantz et al. 2000). The dark color means that sunlight is not being reflected; the absorbed energy raises the temperature of the pavement and thus the temperature ofthe air that is near it. This immediately contributes to the heating ofthe city. When the temperature gets high enough, the modern response is to turn on an air conditioner that further heats the outside air and costs energy. The atmosphere also responds by using the thermal energy to drive the conversion of organic gases and nitrous oxides into smog. There is thus a cost in both energy consumed and degradation of the environment (Rosenfeld et al. 1998). These costs may be lessened by coating the pavement with a light-colored material (Pomerantz et al. 1997). We suggested in the earlier report (Pomerantz & Akbari 1998), in addition to detrimental environmental effects, the heating of pavements may be bad for the pavements themselves. The properties of asphalt binder are known to be temperature dependent. For example, the stiffness of asphalt decreases exponentially with temperature (Yang 1972). Likewise, the related property, viscosity, as measured by penetration of a sharp needle, decreases exponentially with temperature (Hunter 1994). The effects of pavement— temperature on performance have been recognized by the Strategic Highway Research Program (SHRP) which grades asphalt according to the pavement temperature range it will endure (Cominsky et a!. 1994). However, asphalt binders that function over wide temperature ranges are more costly. This opens possibilities for additional savings by constructing cooler pavements: by reducing the maximum pavement temperature, a lower grade of asphalt may be acceptable, and/or some failure will be delayed. Ultimately the lifecycle costs of maintenance and disposal ofpavements will be reduced. This paperwill investigate these non-energy or non-environmentally related effects of cooler pavements, both the potential benefits and detriments. Such benefits, in addition to longer lifetime, may include better visibility. The danger of glare seems to be negligible for the suggested reflectivity. We also report some measurements on the relationship between the reflectivity of aggregates and chip seals made of them. The evidence suggests that cooler pavements may offer impressive benefits to society, and thus warrant further study.
Effect of Pavement Temperature on Durability
AC pavements fail by a variety of mechanisms, some of which are temperature dependent. Some failures might be delayed or eliminated if the pavements were more reflective of sunlight and their temperatures were thereby decreased. First we establish the order of magnitude of the effect of the reflectivity of a pavement on its temperature. The reflectivity averaged over the solar spectrum is the albedo2, a. Measurements (Pomerantz et a!. 2000b) were made of pavement temperatures in Berkeley and San Ramon, CA. In Berkeley, data were taken at about 3 PM on new, old, and light-color coated asphalt pavements. The data from San Ramon were taken at about 3 PM on four asphalt concrete and one Portland cement concrete (a = 0.35) pavements. In both places, the solar energy fluxes were about 1000 Wm2. A decrease of about 4 °C(7 °F)was observed for an increase of albedo of 0.1. (Fig. 1) (A change in albedeo of 0.25 is the difference between fresh black AC, with a = 0.05, and Portland cement concrete, with a 0.3.)
A theory of maximum pavement temperature versus albedo predicts a decrease in temperature of 3.6 °C(6.5°F)for a 0.1 increase in a, for conditions of insolation, time and low wind-speed roughly similar to the measurements (Solaimanian & Kennedy 1993). Their result is in reasonable agreement with the data ofFig. 1. Other calculations more specific to the conditions ofthe experiments give similar results (Pomerantz et al. 2000b). Thus it may be possible to reduce the peak pavement temperatures by upwards of 5 °Cby increasing the albedo by a practical amount ofabout 0.2.
The pavement temperature may affect the rate ofpavement failures. There are several distress mechanisms of AC that are likely to be influenced by pavement temperature (Yoder &Witzak 1975) including:
• rutting: tires cause channel-like depressions in the pavement
• shoving: theAC is pushed along the direction oftire motion
• aging: asphalt becomes brittle and stiffer with age
• fatigue damage: gradual cracking of pavement
• bleeding: asphalt binder accumulates at the surface
It is well known (Croney & Croney 1998) that the stiffness of asphalt depends strongly on temperature. The exponential dependence of viscosity on temperature results in about an order of magnitude decrease in viscosity for a 10°Cincrease in temperature. The stiffness ofAC also decreases exponentially as its temperature increases: a 10°Cincrease in temperature can cause a factor of 2 decrease in the stiffness of AC. Stiffness is thought to be an indicator of pavement resistance to rutting and fatigue, which would suggest that the lifetime of the pavement might increase if the temperature of the pavement were lowered (Pomerantz&Akbari 1998). We have conducted experiments to measure this effect.
Effect of Temperature on Aging
Aging of pavements is also believed to involve chemical and physical reactions that are speeded by higher temperatures. As a pavement ages the asphalt becomes stiffer and more brittle. This can lead to cracking. The following is some evidence on the effects ofhigh pavement temperature on aging.
Measurements on asphalt extracted from test sections of pavements ( Page et al. 1985) showed that the viscosity increased with age. This “hardening” might be thought to enhance lifetime since “stiffness” is believed to be beneficial for thick pavements. Stiffening is not good for thinner pavements where flexibility prevents cracking. Embrittlement leads to cracking in sudden, single events. The cause is a loss of volatile hydrocarbons, and some oxidation and polymerization. It has been observed that the embrittlement increases with temperature and the intensity of ultraviolet light (Kumar & Goetz 1977); the oxidation rate doubled for every increase of 10 °C(Dickinson 1980).
Tests in various climates in California showed that desert conditions lead to relatively rapid decreases in ductility, as well as increased viscosity (described as “hardening”) (Kemp & Predoehl 1981). Fig. 4 shows the dramatic effect of weathering in a hot and sunny desert climate. The average viscosity of several asphalts exposed to a desert climate with an annual average air temperature of23°C (73 °F)for about 4 years is 10 times higher than when the average temperature was 17°C (63°F).The dependence on temperature seems to be nonlinear; the hardening rate accelerates when the average air temperature exceeds about 13°C (55°F).In these studies, the embrittlement that contributes to road failure is assumed to be due to the same mechanism that increases the viscosity. Thus the embrittlement is likely to decrease if the temperature of the pavement could be decreased. The authors correlate their results with air temperatures but they recognize that it is the asphalt temperature that is crucial and controllable. They conclude that the durability of asphalt can be improved by “the insulating ofthe asphalt concrete mat with a cover such as a reflective chip seal in hot areas.” A reflective seal has the benefits of both lowering the asphalt temperature and reducing the ultraviolet light damage.
Thus, the durability of roads against various modes of failure can be enhanced by preventing the pavement temperature from becoming too high.
Effects of Reflective Pavements on Illumination
If pavements are more reflective, illumination at night is enhanced by the light reflected offthe pavement. Thus both traffic signs and pedestrians may become easier to see. According to the International Commission on Illumination (CIE 1984) “In order to make asphalt pavements lighter, some countries (e. g. Denmark) stipulate the inclusion of a proportion ofwhite stones in the bituminous concrete. In Belgium, the use of light-colored stones for chip..sprinkling..is obligatory on the major roads of the State network.” The need for better lighting will become greater because ofthe aging ofthe population. A consequence ofthe aging of drivers is that it becomes more important that traffic signs and their supports be larger and clearer, increasing their costs. Enhanced visibility due to reflective pavements will help avoid accidents and reduce the costs of automobile insurance. In addition, better illumination probably reduces auto theft and other street crimes.
We made a quantitative estimate of the contribution of pavement reflectivity to the illumination of a subject for the geometry of Fig. 5. Part of the illumination of a subject is by light directly from the luminaire, and partly by light reflected off the pavement.
Fig. 5. Geometry of a subject illuminated by a street lamp (luminaire) and a pavement
In a more detailed paper (Pomerantz et a!. 2000a), we show that the ratio of the light reflected offthe pavement, q~,to the light arriving directly from the street light, q~,is qr/qd~9~ (1) where Qis the reflectivity for the spectrum of visible light emitted by the lamp5. For a !R.~° 0.1, the contribution of reflected light is about 10%; if 9?..= 0.3 the reflected light increases to about 30% of the direct light. This offers the possibility of using fewer or less powerful street lamps, or leaving these unchanged and receiving greater illumination. Our estimate of about 20% reduction in the required strength of the light sources by changing reflectivity from 10% to 30% is similar to the results of a rather different calculation of the number of light fixtures needed to achieve a desired level of illumination with different pavement reflectances (Stark 1986).
The actual visibility depends not only on illumination but also on contrast, which is not an issue here because it depends on the background, which is uncontrolled. Higher reflectivity does not imply unacceptable glare. The maximum albedos contemplated here are about 0.35, similar to cement concrete. Cement concrete roads are in widespread use around the world; the reader of this article has likely ridden on some. One does not hear that the users of such roads are suffering from glare. It seems likely that AC pavements with such reflectivities will not cause problems from glare.
[edit]
Conclusions
That high pavement temperatures lead to more rapid deterioration of roads is anticipated by civil engineers. The concept is embodied in the Superpave specifications for the choice of the grade of asphalt binder: one of the criteria for the grade of asphalt is the highest temperatures the pavement is expected to endure. The experiments with the Heavy Vehicle Simulator reported here show quantitatively that at pavement temperatures greater than 40 °Cthe amount ofrutting increases dramatically. Similarly, under simple shear stress, samples suffer larger permanent shear distortion when their temperatures are elevated. Temperatures greater than 50 °C,at which the pavements degrade more rapidly, are known to occur in actual roads even in temperate climates. The traditional means to strengthen pavements is to use a modified or high-grade asphalt binder. An alternative is to make the pavement cooler by reflecting the sunlight before it is absorbed. If the surface of the pavement is kept cooler, the gradient ofthe temperature inside the pavement will obviously be smaller. The peak pavement temperature can be reduced by about 4°Cfor each increase of 0.1 ofalbedo.
One suggested method ofincreasing the albedo is to cover the pavement with a single layer of aggregate. When used as a repair technique this procedure is known as a chip-seal. Our experiments show that the albedos of chip-seals are about 70% of the albedos of the aggregates. A similar technique may also be applicable to new AC construction — by spreading white aggregate as the final layer and rolling it into the pavement. In cases where a high grade or modified asphalt is called for, it might be cheaper to place an additional layer of aggregate. The possibility of covering a road with a thin layer of cement concrete- thin white topping— is being researched in the industry.
More-reflective pavements have the benefits of adding to the effectiveness of street lighting and automobile headlights. Our result for a representative case is that the ratio of reflected light to direct light is approximately equal to the visible reflectivity. Changing from surfaces that are 10% reflecting to 30% would result in 20% more light from luminaires reaching a subject in the middle of a street.
Our laboratory findings indicate that cooler pavements may be considerably more durable against rutting and embrittlement. We believe that tests should now be made on actual functioning roads. Then the effects of time dependent temperatures and flows of traffic will be revealed. The possible benefits of more reflective, cooler pavements are worthy of this serious attention because this might lead to significant reduction in the huge expenditures on the nation’s roads.
Monday, 26 December 2011
//
Labels:
Engineering
//
0
comments
//
0 comments to "Cooler Reflective Pavements an energy saving!"
vfg
Search
About This Blog
Popular Posts
-
The Fuji Instax Mini 25 and Instax Mini 7S are a couple of moment picture zoom lens utilizing Fuji's Visa measured moment picture. In th...
-
When I pulled the Fujifilm Instax 200 out of my picture clicker pack at a familiar Sunday outing to a neighborhood small time baseball amuse...
-
The above picture is one of the most famous picture in the world. If you are the requester band Rage Against The Machine, the picture above...
-
The hotel room sports a modern yet cozy design and everything you need is provided for. The bed is super comfortable and remains the thing I...
-
Radisson - Blu Hotel , Berlin Germany is the world's largest cylindrical aquarium , named Aquadom . It is 25 meters ...
Feedjit

Post a Comment